The Copy Cartel Website Copy Check-up
A practical guide to finding out why your website isn't doing its job.
Your website has a job. Is it doing it?
Seven printable pages. Ten checks covering your message, offer, audience, trust and next step. A score out of twenty, with advice on what to fix first.
No marketing fog. No conversion promises. Just useful questions and space to work out the answers.
Take a look inside.
0 / No or unclear · 1 / Partly · 2 / Clearly yes
01 What do you actually do?
Could a stranger describe your business after reading the first screen?
Name the product or service, who it is for and the problem it solves. Swap 'innovative solutions' for the actual job.
Try this: Ask someone outside the business to explain the homepage back to you. Do not help them.
02 A reason to stay
Does the headline give the right visitor a useful reason to read on?
Start with a specific need, outcome or offer, not a welcome or a claim to be leading.
Try this: Write a headline a customer could recognise as relevant to their situation.
03 An offer, not a mystery
Is it clear what someone can buy or ask you to do?
Explain what is included, who it suits and what happens next. Name important limits.
Try this: Find the page where a customer can understand the offer without calling to decode it.
04 The right reader
Does the copy speak to the people who are likely to need this?
Use the questions and language real customers bring to you. Not everybody is your audience.
Try this: Compare the copy with three recent customer questions. Which ones does it answer?
05 Benefits people notice
Can visitors see how your work makes their situation better?
Connect a feature to a practical benefit. A monthly report might mean spotting late payments before they become a problem.
Try this: After each feature, ask 'So what?' Write the useful answer, without promising what you cannot deliver.
06 Questions answered
Does the page address the doubts that stop customers taking the next step?
Explain process, suitability, costs or how quotes work, responsibilities and relevant constraints. Do not bury every answer in an FAQ.
Try this: Ask whoever handles enquiries which question they answer most. Put the answer where it is needed.
07 A next step worth taking
Does the CTA say what happens after the click?
Use one primary next step per offer. 'Request a quote' beats 'Learn more' when that is what the visitor receives.
Try this: Check the button and destination together. They should make the same promise.
08 Trust that is earned
Are important claims supported by evidence visitors can check?
Use real process details, accurate qualifications, permissioned testimonials or verifiable examples. Never invent proof.
Try this: Circle every 'best', 'leading' and performance promise. Support it, qualify it or cut it.
09 A sensible reading order
Can someone skim the headings and still understand the offer?
Arrange the page around the reader's decision: what it is, why it matters, why believe it, what next.
Try this: Read only the headings. Move anything that answers a question before the question has arisen.
10 A human voice
Would a real person say these sentences to a customer?
Read aloud. Cut unnecessary words and explain specialist terms when the audience needs help. Keep useful personality.
Try this: Replace one abstract sentence with a concrete explanation. Plain does not mean dull.